Social media growth tools often promise the world, but do they actually work? I decided to test Creator Buddy by Alex Finn over 7 days to see if it could help me grow on X (Twitter).
Here’s the full, honest, day-by-day account of what happened.
Day 1 – Wednesday – First Impressions
I finally decided to start using Creator Buddy after putting it off because I didn’t want to spend $50 upfront.
I’d been checking out affiliate programs for Threads, but MomentumHive hadn’t approved me yet.
Creator Buddy’s simple system was easy to understand, which was promising.
Logging in via browser, I noticed I didn’t have to link my X account directly.
The “Reply Guy” function allowed me to type a reply, hit the paper dart button, and it opened a window ready to post on X.
No AI-generated replies yet — maybe another tool does that.
The feed refreshes every 4 hours to avoid spam — smart. Typing and sending replies was smooth, much easier than using the phone.
My goal was 50 replies a day.
I had my profile linking to my website and an experimental Temu affiliate link. By the end of the day, I nearly hit 100 replies, mostly thoughtful responses.
Day 2 – Thursday – Momentum Builds
After a late night with a plumbing issue while hosting a guest at my short-term rental, I got back on Creator Buddy.
The feed had new posts, and I knew I couldn’t fake engagement — I actually needed to have something to say. Some posts were banal, but replying thoughtfully boosted stats.
Scheduling posts from the “Algo Analyzer” helped. I sent over 50 replies, mainly from the For You feed rather than Creator Buddy itself.
Consistent engagement is more about thoughtful replies than sheer automation.
X could become a platform to promote my Medium/blog articles as I publish them, which I’d already been experimenting with.
Day 3 – Friday – Falling Off
Reached 51 replies, then totally fell off. My social life interruptions caught up — I missed a friend’s art opening due to misunderstanding the invite.
Balancing personal life with social media growth is trickier than it sounds.
So here I was, living out in real time the reality that consistency is key, and life can disrupt even the best-laid plans.
Day 4 – Saturday – Spiral
I left the house for coffee, visited the markets, and caught up with an artist friend at his gallery.
Later, I went to multiple pubs and ended up sleeping with two people, one of whom gave me bad drugs.
Unfortunately the chaos impacted my ability to grow on X.
Lesson learned: your mental and physical state directly affects online performance.
Day 5 – Sunday – Pause
I spent the day recovering. The strange man was still in my house, which reminded me to prioritize self-care over social media growth.
He was really nice, incidentally, but he had to go. I had him home before sundown.
Creator Buddy wasn’t failing me — my life choices were affecting my consistency.
Day 6 – Monday – Consequences
Second night without sleep — What?
I was terrified.
I called Healthline, and a nurse asked if anyone could take me to the ER.
Lately I’ve been in this state of mind where I don’t think anyone is really my friend — just glorified acquaintances.
That’s probably why I still use Twitter.
She asked me if I knew anyone in my town. I whinged, “Yeah, like 200 people.”
Thankfully my dad was visiting and helped. Good thing he’s still alive.
At the emergency room, I saw three people I’m friends with. One of them was in there for shingles, the other one I didn’t talk to, and the last one was… an employee.
Day 7 – Tuesday – Verdict and Lessons
Creator Buddy didn’t fail me — I failed Creator Buddy. Here are my biggest takeaways:
- The Reply Guy feature isn’t necessary — the For You feed or Following feed is enough for thoughtful replies.
- It’s also thoughtful for people to communicate clearly both online and in person so that you don’t miss out on events you could’ve attended
- Consistency matters. Engaging every day, even with 50 thoughtful replies, yields more results than cramming hundreds at once.
- I found it way easier to work on this from a computer with a keyboard — the smartphone interface becomes increasingly obnoxious
- Creator Buddy has a lot of potentially powerful features that if used right, and by the right person (not an unhinged drunk), with consistent actions you can really shine with the help of this tool
- It’s definitely worth trying, and investing in the subscription if you can commit to using it consistently, and staying off drugs
- Start on a Monday. Don’t be like me.
Conclusion
This 7-day experiment taught me that tools like Creator Buddy can help grow your X presence, but personal discipline, thoughtful engagement, and consistent effort are more important than any automation.
If you’re serious about growth, start with consistent replies and quality interactions.
If you want to join, start here for free!
Check out these tools to start growing your X account today:
Related posts you might like:
Leave a Reply